Nails
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Business

Reader to Reader: Are DIY nail products good or bad for the professional industry?

May 13, 2011

Bad bad bad. When consumers buy these products and use them without any professional training they don’t learn proper technique, application, or maintenance. They risk ruining their nail beds or someone else’s and can pass infections from one person to the next (if they are providing the service to someone other than themselves), not to mention risking their own personal health! They have no clue as to what to watch for. I don’t even like the idea of full-coverage DIY nails because they can rip away the nail beds. I think they should only have access to basic nail files, polishes, etc.
Bobbi Morgan
Liquid Sun Nails, Prince Rupert,
British Columbia, Canada

There are two reasons I feel they are bad. First of all it takes away from my income. That’s the greedy side of me that rarely shows. Secondly, DIY nail products make the average Jane think she knows everything there is to know about nails. Unfortunately, the consumer is not fully educated on all the diseases and disorders of the nail. I worry they will harm themselves or others due to lack of information.
Melissa Fuge
The Foxy Lady, Klamath Falls, Ore.

One thing we have to remember is that if stores sell DIY nail product kits, then people may well give them a try. And they will always make a mess of it and realize we are not just some air-headed bimbos who sit pretty painting nails. We are qualified and do our jobs properly! I think a lot of hairdressers must feel the same way, but they are still very much in business and so are we.
Judy Archibald
Manchester, England

When I was a teenager I bought DIY products, developed a passion for nail care and nail enhancements, and now over a decade later I share my passion with potential nail care professionals as a nail instructor.
Toyia Brown
Rivertown School of Beauty, Columbus, Ga.

The average consumer and/or unlicensed professional who tries to do nails at home doesn’t really scare me as far as business goes. Clearly, they’re not who I want as a customer in my salon (although I would love to change their perspective). Unfortunately, there are just too many enhancement products available to the public. Without education, damaging results occur. Guess who gets the bad rap? The entire nail industry. I do not enjoy hearing the horror stories from somewhere else, but I look at it as part of my job to educate anyone who sits at my table. So get ready for an earful if you slam my industry.
Robin Jones
Robin’s Nest Professional Nail Care,
London, Ohio

There’s nothing wrong in doing some DIY to the nails as long as the instructions are followed properly. It gives us ladies time to experiment and some time to ourselves! I started out this way and it led me to my career, which I love. Nothing is as good as the real thing though — DIY products are not the best quality and they make you realize what a good job nail techs do. So it’s very good for us because we have skills and passion that the DIY products can never touch. Clients know a good professional service when they get one and always come back (especially after experimenting themselves, even with nail polish).
Cheryl Wigley-Douce
Laid’eez Salon & Spa, Derby, England


Illustration by Ajay Peckham

More FAQ

What’s the best way to recruit techs for a new salon?

I’m opening a new nail salon and am having a hard time finding nail techs besides myself. How did you find yours? I’ve tried Craigslist, cosmetology schools, and beauty supply stores. Any suggestions? — Jen McClain, owner, Completely Polished (www.completelypolished.com), Cranberry Township, Pa.... read more

What low-cost extras do you provide that clients perceive as having a high value?

A complimentary glass of wine, an extra-long foot massage … these are the small gestures that keep clients coming back — and sending their friends to your salon. We asked techs: What low-cost extras do you provide that clients perceive as having a high value?... read more

Should the salon owner do nails herself?

Should the salon owner do nails herself ?... read more

Services For Teenagers

I’ve gotten requests from a few moms to add services for teenagers to our menu. I don’t mean the “little princess” 12 and-under service, but the 14 to 18 set. Their input has been that they will get their nails done more often, but can’t justify the full, luxury spa experience. I’ve been thinking about doing a “teen night” each week with really basic mani/pedi options (no massage, no callus care, etc. — just shaping, light cuticle work, polish and lotion application) that focus on trendy colors and options for spirit manis in school colors, etc. What do you think is the best way to address this demographic?... read more

How do you react to negative feedback?

Reader to Reader: How do you react to negative feedback about your business on social sites like Yelp and Facebook? Do you respond publicly or privately?... read more

Starting a Salon

I’m just about to graduate from esthetics school in Canada. I would like to open a small salon that focuses mainly on pedicures. I’m at a loss as to where to start, beginning with what products to use. I would like to offer at least two different product lines. I would like my pedicures to make a difference (detox, make feet feel relaxed and smooth and happy). Any suggestions?... read more

Is it Better to Buy?

Is it better to buy?... read more

Will gel-polish cause traditional polish to become obsolete?

Will gel-polish cause traditional polish to become obsolete?... read more

Do Nail Techs Really Need Resumes?

Do Nail Techs Really Need Resumes?... read more

What’s the most unusual place you did nails?

From funeral homes to a Swedish castle to the great outdoors — those are just some of the places you’ve done nails for your clients. We asked readers to tell us the most unusual place they did nails.... read more

I’m an employee on commission and I’m paying for product. Is this fair?

I’m an employee working on commission. My salon has us pay for the product that we use. If, say, we charge $25 for a fill, they deduct $3. Then we get 50% commission on $22 instead of $25. So pretty much we only get 40% in total since 10% is taken off the top to begin with. On a busy day my product costs can be more than $25, so basically I am not getting paid for an hour I worked and one service I did. Is this a common practice and do you think it’s fair?... read more

Do I have to have a website in addition to my Facebook page?

I’ve got a Facebook page that I’m pretty active on, but I don’t have a website for my nail business. Do I really need a website?... read more