Nails
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

CIR Re-Examines Ethyl Methacrylate/ Methacrylate Acid

by Staff
March 1, 1999
2 min to read


The NMC and ABA appeared before the Cosmetic Ingredient Review Panel (CIR) (an independent expert panel of scientists that makes recommendations to the FDA), in Washington, D.C., on December 3, 1998, to testify on the safety of ethyl methacrylate and methacrylic acid and its esters for use in sculptured nail care products.

The NMC’s appearance was prompted by a petition filled by the Methacrylate Producers Association (MPA), a trade association of several large producers of methacylates, urging the CIR to reconsider its 1994 ruling, which proclaimed ethyl methacrylate acid and its esters as safe for use in nail care products.

Ad Loading...

Representing the NMC were Eric Schwartz of OPI Products and chairman of the NMC Safety and Standards Committee; Doug Schoon of Creative Nail Design (also a committee member); and Dr. Ed Jackson, an expert toxicologist retained by the ABA and NMC.

Commenting on the investigation, Schoon indicated his opinion that it is simply a “legal maneuver” by the CIR to avert potential liability issues for itself, and that it really does not represent any real threat to the nail industry.

“I don’t think that the MPA is going to pursue it,” Schoon says. “They’ve done their presentation, they’ve done their thing and raised the issue, and now the CIR will look at it and I think ultimately they will decide in favor the nail industry.”

“They just wanted to review the data, and I think they are going to re-confirm their [1994] ruling.”

The ABA and NMC group testified that ethyl methacrylate and methacylic acid and its esters (except one already regulated by the FDA) are safe when used by trained nail technicians. They cited scientific data showing that methacrylates as a class are only weak allergens and that there have been few incidents of allergies reported to the FDA or industry soruces, Also, they focused on the professional nature of the industry and the significant licensing, education, and training that is required of nail technicians.

Ad Loading...

Dr. Jackson also noted the side use of methacrylates in the biomedical field, such as in prostheses, surgical cement, contact lenses, and hearing devices without problems.

As of press time, the CIR has not announced any formal action on the MPA request, but has a meeting scheduled for March 3.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Business

A row of styling stations at JBW Jeffrey Ching Salon
Business|Articles|Mar 3, 2026

Precision, Passion, and the Business of Beauty

When Bowie Lau and Jeffrey Ching opened JBW Jeffrey Ching Salon in 2011, they weren’t just launching another luxury hair destination—they were building a business rooted in passion, artistry, and thoughtful growth.

Sponsored by Amex

Ad Loading...
Business|Articles|Nov 27, 2024

Prepare for Small Business Saturday® with American Express

The busy holiday season is here, and with it comes jam-packed days, last-minute client requests and booming retail sales. For many salon owners, the highlight of the season is Small Business Saturday® (SBS). This year on Saturday, November 30, consumers can take their shopping into the small businesses in their communities.

Sponsored by Amex

Ad Loading...
Business|Articles|Oct 22, 2024

Success at the Top: Thriving on Madison Ave.

Salon owner Nuri Yurt had a dream of owning a salon on New York City’s Madison Avenue. "Through perseverance, hard work and stellar customer service, he and partner John Kaygisiz founded Toka Salon in 2007.

Sponsored by Amex

Business|Articles|Sep 6, 2024

Vagaro’s New AI Features and Communication Tool Pave the Way for a More Efficient, Profitable Business

Vagaro has consistently been at the forefront of salon software technology, helping businesses be more efficient, create more effective communication, and even improve company culture. Now, Connect by Vagaro, the platform’s two-way communication capability, and Vagaro’s new generative AI tools are giving owners new opportunities to grow and expand.

Sponsored by Vagaro

Business|Articles|Aug 6, 2024

5 Things I Won't Do as a Nail Tech

This list of watch-outs from @jodydoesjels prompted us to reach out to her and learn more. We had already fallen for her hand-painted designs and now we wanted to know more about this list she created to help clients decide if she was the nail tech for them.

Ad Loading...